Online. On The Phone. Through The Mail. Pay Your Insurance Premium – The Way That Works Best for You. Submit Your Claim through Ayres Insurance Agency, Inc. or Directly to your Insurance Carrier. Whether you want to pay your insurance premium by mail, by phone or online, Ayres Insurance Agency helps you pay your bill. If you need to submit a claim after normal business hours, you can contact your insurance carrier directly.
Click on company logo to jump to more info.
Payment methods: check, debit card, Visa, MasterCard, American Express & Discover. No fee to pay online or by phone.
American Modern Insurance Group
- Pay online: www.amig.com
- Pay by phone: 800.543.264
- Pay by mail: P.O. Box 5323, Cincinnati, OH 45201
- Submit a claim by phone: 1-800-543-2644
Payment methods: check, debit card, Visa, MasterCard & Discover. No fee to pay online with Visa, MasterCard or e-check; $5 fee for Discover and payments by phone
Erie Insurance Group
- Pay online: www.erieinsurance.com
- Pay by phone: 800-458-0811
- Pay by mail: 100 Erie Insurance Place, Erie, PA 16530
- Submit a claim by phone: 1-800-367-3743 or online at www.erieinsurance.com
Payment methods: check, debit card, Visa, MasterCard & Discover. No fee to pay online with Visa, MasterCard or e-check; $5 fee for Discover and payments by phone
Erie Family Life Insurance Company
- Pay online: www.erieinsurance.com
- Pay by phone: 800-458-0811
- Pay by mail: 100 Erie Insurance Place, Erie, PA 16530
- Submit a claim by phone: 1-800-367-3743 or online at www.erieinsurance.com
Payment methods: check, debit card, Visa & MasterCard. No fee to pay online or by phone.
Foremost Insurance Group
- Pay online: www.foremost.com
- Pay by phone: 800-532-4221
- Pay by mail: P.O. Box 3333, Grand Rapids, MI 49501
- Submit a claim by phone: 1-800-527-3905 or online at www.foremost.com
Payment methods: check, debit card, Visa & MasterCard. No fee to pay online or by phone.
Frederick Mutual
- Pay online: www.frederickmutual.com
- Pay by phone: 800-544-8737
- Pay by mail: 57 Thomas Johnson Drive, Frederick, MD 21702
- Submit a claim by phone: 1-866-212-5246 or online at www.frederickmutual.com
Payment methods: check, debit card, Visa, MasterCard & Discover. No fee to pay online or by phone.
Grange Insurance
- Pay online: www.grangeinsurance.com
- Pay by phone: 800-425-1100
- Pay by mail: P.O. Box 740604, Cincinnati, OH 45274
- Submit a claim by phone: 1-800-445-3030 or online at www.grangeinsurance.com
Payment methods: check, debit card, credit card.
The Hartford Insurance
- Pay online: www.thehartford.com
- Pay by phone: 866-467-8730
- Enroll in mobile applications for your smartphone
- Submit a claim by phone: 1-800-327-3636
Payment methods: check, debit card, Visa, MasterCard & Discover. $4.95 fee to pay online or by phone.
Main Street America Group
- Pay online: www.msagroup.com
- Pay by phone: 800-611-0958
- Pay by mail: P.O. Box 2004, Keene, NH 03431
- Enroll in EFT program
- Submit a claim by phone: 1-877-425-2467 or online at www.msagroup.com
Payment methods: check, debit card, Visa, MasterCard & Discover. No fee to pay online or by phone.
Progressive Insurance
- Pay online: www.progressive.com
- Pay by phone: 877-776-2436
- Pay by mail: Dept 0561 Carol Stream, IL 60132-0561
- Submit a claim by phone: 1-800-925-2886 or online at www.progressive.com
Payment methods: check, debit card, Visa, MasterCard, American Express & Discover. No fee to pay online or by phone.
Safeco Insurance
- Pay online: www.safeco.com
- Pay by phone: 800-332-3226
- Pay by mail: P.O. Box 6476, Carol Stream, IL 60197
- Submit a claim by phone: 1-877-566-6001 or online at www.safeco.com
Payment methods: check, debit card, Visa, MasterCard & Discover. No fee to pay online or by phone.
Travelers Insurance
- Pay online: www.travelers.com
- Pay by phone: 800-842-5075
- Pay by mail: P.O. Box 660307, Dallas, TX 75266
- Submit a claim by phone: 1-800-252-4633 or online at www.travelers.com